Southwestern Energy Production Co., or SEPCO, a subsidiary of Southwestern Energy Co., Houston, (NYSE: SWN), has filed its first response to unfounded allegations contained in a lawsuit pending in federal court. The lawsuit claims that SEPCO's drilling operations in Lenox Township, Pennsylvania, contaminated nearby water wells.
In the motion to dismiss, which was recently filed in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, SEPCO challenges the legal basis for several parts of the complaint. The court will review the motion and the briefs to be filed by the parties and decide how much of the lawsuit will be permitted to proceed. At this stage of the lawsuit, the rules only allow SEPCO to challenge the complaint on legal grounds.
As the case moves forward, SEPCO will have the opportunity to place the facts before the court. The complaint alleges that SEPCO's hydraulic fracturing activities contaminated nearby water wells with barium, manganese and strontium. However, neither the drilling fluids nor the fracturing fluids utilized by SEPCO contained any of these substances. Barium is one of the most common elements in the earth's crust and occurs naturally in many water supplies, which has been noted by both federal and state agencies. An August 2007 report by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services specifically identified Pennsylvania as a state with many communities that "have drinking water where barium content is up to 10 times higher than the Environmental Protection Agency's recommended maximum concentration level." Further, water samples from the area taken prior to the commencement of SEPCO's drilling operations indicated barium readings in excess of federal and state limits.
"SEPCO takes very seriously its obligation to operate safely and is committed to working with the governmental agencies and local communities to ensure that our operations do not adversely impact the environment near our work sites," says Mark Boling, executive vice president and general counsel, Southwestern Energy. "We have worked with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection with respect to our operations in Lenox Township in order to confirm that our operations were not the source of any concern and that people residing in close proximity to our work sites had safe water to use."
"We are concerned that lawyers for the plaintiffs in this lawsuit are making statements in the media that we believe are demonstrably wrong. The allegations in this lawsuit are serious, and the parties should make their cases in court with accurate, scientific evidence rather than in the press with statements that have no support in any evidence SEPCO has seen."
Southwestern has oil and gas assets in Arkansas, Oklahoma and Texas.
Recommended Reading
Aethon Cuts Rigs but Wants More Western Haynesville Acreage
2024-03-28 - Private gas E&P Aethon Energy has drilled some screamers in its far western Haynesville Shale play—and the company wants to do more in the area.
Energy Transition in Motion (Week of March 28, 2024)
2024-03-28 - Here is a look at some of this week’s renewable energy news, including proposals submitted to develop about 6.8 gigawatts of wind projects offshore Connecticut, Massachusetts and Rhode Island.
SLB to Acquire Majority Stake in Aker Carbon Capture
2024-03-28 - SLB and Aker Carbon Capture plan to combine their technology portfolios, expertise and operations platforms to bring carbon capture technologies to market faster and more economically, SLB said in a news release.
CERAWeek: Tecpetrol CEO Touts Argentina Conventional, Unconventional Potential
2024-03-28 - Tecpetrol CEO Ricardo Markous touted Argentina’s conventional and unconventional potential saying the country’s oil production would nearly double by 2030 while LNG exports would likely evolve over three phases.
DUG GAS+: Chesapeake in Drill-but-don’t-turn-on Mode
2024-03-28 - COO Josh Viets said Chesapeake is cutting costs and ready to take advantage once gas prices rebound.