ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP) has revised down over a billion barrels (Bbbl) of oil sands reserves because of low global crude prices, a company filing showed on Feb. 22, the latest sign that some of Canada's vast hydrocarbon potential may be left untapped.
The U.S. oil major said developed and undeveloped reserves of bitumen—the heavy viscous oil found in northern Alberta's remote oil sands—totalled 1.2 Bbbl at the end of 2016, down from 2.4 Bbbl at the end of 2015.
The oil sands have some of the highest full-cycle breakeven costs in the world, with new thermal projects needing West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude prices around $60/bbl. WTI crude futures settled at $54.33/bbl on Feb. 21.
The U.S. Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) document provides a detailed breakdown of the global reserves cut ConocoPhillips announced in quarterly results in early February when it debooked 1.75 Bboe of reserves.
Al Hirshberg, ConocoPhillips' executive vice president for production, drilling and projects, told investors on the quarterly call the company expects to rebook the reserves if current prices hold.
Likewise Martin King, an analyst with GMP FirstEnergy in Calgary, Alberta, said the debooking likely had more to do with SEC rules requiring companies to evaluate economic reserves at year-end.
But the fact that the oil sands make up 70% of the reduction underlines how much of Canada's resources are uneconomic in a weaker oil environment.
"They [the oil sands] are at the upper end of the cost curve," said Judith Dwarkin, chief economist at RS Energy Group in Calgary. "It may or may not speak to future similar events from other producers."
Calgary-based Imperial Oil Ltd. (NYSE MKT: IMO), which is majority-owned by ExxonMobil Corp. (NYSE: XOM), debooked 2.6 Bbbl of reserves in January.
ConocoPhillips made the reserve reductions at the Surmont, Foster Creek, Christina Lake and Narrow Lakes projects.
Surmont is operated by ConocoPhillips and a joint venture (JV) with Total E&P Canada, a unit of Total SA (NYSE: TOT), and the other three are JVs run by Cenovus Energy Inc. (NYSE: CVE).
Total also debooked undeveloped reserves at Surmont, according to SEC filings. But Cenovus, which reports to Canadian securities authorities, said its total proved reserves including non-oil sands operations rose 5% in 2016 vs. a year earlier.
Cenovus spokesman Reg Curren said the company assumed different rules relating to reserves reporting in Canada and the U.S. were behind the difference.
Recommended Reading
Waha NatGas Prices Go Negative
2024-03-14 - An Enterprise Partners executive said conditions make for a strong LNG export market at an industry lunch on March 14.
Summit Midstream Launches Double E Pipeline Open Season
2024-04-02 - The Double E pipeline is set to deliver gas to the Waha Hub before the Matterhorn Express pipeline provides sorely needed takeaway capacity, an analyst said.
Pembina Pipeline Enters Ethane-Supply Agreement, Slow Walks LNG Project
2024-02-26 - Canadian midstream company Pembina Pipeline also said it would hold off on new LNG terminal decision in a fourth quarter earnings call.
EQT CEO: Biden's LNG Pause Mirrors Midstream ‘Playbook’ of Delay, Doubt
2024-02-06 - At a Congressional hearing, EQT CEO Toby Rice blasted the Biden administration and said the same tactics used to stifle pipeline construction—by introducing delays and uncertainty—appear to be behind President Joe Biden’s pause on LNG terminal permitting.
Energy Transfer Asks FERC to Weigh in on Williams Gas Project
2024-04-08 - Energy Transfer's filing continues the dispute over Williams’ development of the Louisiana Energy Gateway.